Periodontal Assessment and Staging
A 46-year-old man who smokes 20 cigarettes a day and has type 2 diabetes (HbA1c 8.9 percent) is referred by the dentist for periodontal assessment and non-surgical therapy. Bleeding on probing is present at 48 percent of sites, several molars have probing depths of 6 to 7 mm, and 36 and 46 have Class II furcation involvement. Radiographs show bone loss into the middle third of the roots, 55 percent at 46, and one tooth has been lost to periodontitis. How would you assess and manage him?
What the panel is testing: Whether you can stage and grade periodontitis with the 2017 classification, plan stepwise non-surgical care, and work within the dentist's prescription.
Show the answer outline
Knowledge: Under the 2017 classification, bone loss into the middle third, probing depths of 6 mm or more, Class II furcations and tooth loss of up to four teeth to periodontitis put him in Stage III. Grade uses the ratio of percentage bone loss to age: 55 divided by 46 is above 1.0, which is Grade C. Smoking at least 10 cigarettes a day and an HbA1c of 7 percent or more are also Grade C modifiers. Diabetes and periodontitis affect each other. The EFP S3 guideline sets out four steps: risk factor control and plaque control, subgingival instrumentation, treatment of residual pockets, then supportive care.
Management: I would record a full chart and share my staging with the dentist, who confirms the diagnosis and plan. Step 1 is tailored oral hygiene instruction with interdental brushes, supragingival plaque and calculus removal, and brief smoking cessation advice. With consent I would inform his physician. Step 2 is subgingival instrumentation with hand and ultrasonic instruments, with local anaesthesia as the dentist and facility scope allow. The guideline does not support routine systemic antibiotics, and prescribing them is not my role. I would re-evaluate after a healing period of several weeks; residual pockets of 6 mm or more, or 5 mm with bleeding, go back to the dentist or periodontist for step 3. He then needs supportive care at short intervals set by his risk.
Ethics and communication: I would explain his diagnosis and its links with smoking and diabetes without blame, and gain consent for each stage. I work to the dentist's prescription and report findings back rather than change the plan myself. For a fasting patient with diabetes, I would time appointments to avoid hypoglycaemia. I would document charts, advice and consent.
Likely panel follow-up questions
- How did you reach Stage III Grade C?
- What does each step of the EFP guideline involve?
- He asks for antibiotics. What do you say?
- What would you do at re-evaluation?
- How would you support him to stop smoking?
Pitfalls in this case
- Calling it gingivitis or mild periodontitis
- Ignoring smoking and diabetes as grade modifiers
- Starting subgingival therapy without the dentist's prescription
- Suggesting or supplying antibiotics
- No re-evaluation or supportive care plan
Reference: Tonetti, Greenwell and Kornman, Staging and grading of periodontitis: framework and proposal of a new classification (J Periodontol 2018); EFP S3 level clinical practice guideline: treatment of stage I to III periodontitis (Sanz et al, J Clin Periodontol 2020)